If Trustpilot removed your reviews
“Bad fit” — and nothing to correct
The obvious question, when a platform removes a profile, is why it did not simply say what was wrong and let the company fix it. The letters answer it in their own words: the ground given was not a review, a rule or an act, but a judgement about the business relationship, reserved to what the letters call Trustpilot’s “sole and absolute discretion”. The agreement those letters were quoting is published, and it is set beside them below.
What the letters actually said
Trustpilot wrote that it “only work[s] with businesses that align with our values and core beliefs … reinforced by our commitment not to do business with companies we consider to be a ‘Bad Fit’ for Trustpilot.”
And: “Under the terms of our agreement with you, Trustpilot has sole and absolute discretion to determine whether it considers a business to be a bad fit.”
Both passages are reproduced from the correspondence, which is published in full on the record page rather than summarised. Read them again and notice what is not in them: no review, no sentence of any review, no policy clause, no conduct, no date, no act.
What the agreement actually says
The letters locate the power in the agreement: “Under the terms of our agreement with you.” That agreement is published, and so is its version history. Trustpilot keeps nine dated versions of its Terms of Use and Sale for Businesses on its own legal site. The one in force on 5 January 2023, the day of the notice, is version 3.0: “These terms come into effect on 10 December 2022.” It had been in force for twenty-six days when they wrote, and the next version is dated October 2023. Retrieved from Trustpilot’s own site on 22 November 2026.
Version 3.0 lists the grounds on which Trustpilot may end a subscription immediately: a material breach left unremedied after fourteen days, or one that cannot be remedied; a breach of the guidelines; abusive or disrespectful conduct toward its staff, partners, users or customers; non-payment; insolvency; a security risk to the platform; and one more. The last is quoted here in full, because it is the one they used: “in our discretion we determine that your business values or core beliefs are in conflict with ours”, which the same clause adds “we may refer to as a bad-fit business”.
Every other ground on that list can be answered by someone other than Trustpilot. A guideline breach can be named, and the Guidelines for Businesses name what counts: fake reviews, incentivized reviews, misuse of the platform, data or brand, products that are not legal. A material breach carries fourteen days to put it right. Conduct toward a person has a date and a description, and can be denied. Non-payment, insolvency and a security risk are all matters of fact. The bad-fit ground is the only one whose subject is Trustpilot’s own opinion of the company, and the only one on the list carrying no remedy period at all.
The letters used that one, and named nothing under it. Not a value. Not a core belief. Not a practice, product, page or ingredient. The letters say Trustpilot works only with businesses that align with its “values and core beliefs”, and version 3.0 is where that phrasing comes from, so the letter was tracking this clause closely. Neither phrase appears anywhere in the Guidelines for Businesses. And where the same agreement requires “at least 30 days’ notice before it ends” for an ordinary termination, this profile was given three working days.
One word is worth weighing. The letters describe the power as “sole and absolute discretion”. Version 3.0, the agreement they were quoting, uses a narrower formula throughout, “in our discretion”, and defines it once at clause 59: “where anything is within our discretion we mean our sole discretion”. Sole settles who decides, and the agreement says it. Absolute would settle whether any standard applies at all, and the agreement does not say it. The word does not appear anywhere in that version of the document.
The same holds in the version Trustpilot publishes today. Version 9.0, in effect from 23 June 2026, still says “in our discretion”, still defines it as sole discretion at clause 59, and still does not contain the word absolute. The bad-fit ground survives into it with one change of wording, from “values or core beliefs” to “values or ethical standards”, and still carries no remedy period.
This record does not read Trustpilot’s mind about why. It reads two documents, both published by Trustpilot, and sets them beside each other: a letter saying the agreement grants sole and absolute discretion, and the agreement it was quoting, in force for twenty-six days at that point, saying sole. Whether that difference matters is for a reader to decide. That it exists is checkable in about two minutes, and both links are below.
Why there was nothing to correct
A company can correct a rule it has broken. It can take down a review that breaks a policy, answer an allegation that a review is fake, or change a practice that a platform objects to. All of those require the platform to say which one.
“Bad fit” is none of those. By its own wording it is a determination about the relationship, not about anything the company did, and it is reserved to one party’s sole and absolute discretion. There is no version of it a company can satisfy, because nothing specific was ever asserted to be unsatisfied. That is not an inference about motive — it is what the clause says.
Alongside it: no individual review was disputed, no review was alleged to be inauthentic, and no policy provision was cited against any review. Three working days later the profile was gone, with its score of 4.9 across 222 reviews and the ranking Trustpilot’s own category page gave it, 2nd of 24 in Herbal Medicine Store.
What this record does not say about it
It does not say the clause was unlawful. It does not say Trustpilot lacked the contractual right to rely on it — the letters assert that right, and this record reproduces the assertion rather than arguing with it. It does not claim to know Trustpilot’s reasons beyond the words it used, and it alleges nothing about any third party.
What it records is the shape of the thing: a discretionary clause, exercised at three working days’ notice, against a profile the platform itself ranked second in its category, with no review identified and no remedy available. A reader can decide for themselves what that is. The facts are stronger stated plainly than argued.
If you have received the same language
Keep the correspondence exactly as received, including headers and dates, and do not paraphrase it anywhere you later publish — quote it. The precise wording is the whole of the evidence, and paraphrase is the fastest way to lose an argument you were winning.
Then capture the profile before the notice period runs out: the score, the count, the distribution, the category ranking and every page of reviews. The capture checklist is twenty minutes of work and it is the difference between a record and a recollection.
Questions
- What does “bad fit” mean on Trustpilot?
- In the correspondence documented here it is a determination that a business does not align with Trustpilot’s stated values and core beliefs, which the letters say Trustpilot has sole and absolute discretion to make under its agreement. The letters identified no review, no policy provision and no conduct.
- Can a company appeal or fix a “bad fit” decision?
- Nothing specific was put to this company that could be fixed, because nothing specific was asserted. What recourse exists in any given case is a question for the agreement in force and for legal advice on the facts; this record documents one case and does not generalise from it.
- Were any reviews said to be fake?
- No. The correspondence disputed no individual review, alleged no review was inauthentic, and cited no policy provision against any review. 102 of the 196 recovered reviews independently match the company’s own order and review database.
Where to go next
- The correspondence, in full
- Trustpilot’s Terms for Businesses, version 3.0 — the one in force on 5 January 2023
- Trustpilot’s Terms for Businesses, the version published today
- Trustpilot’s Guidelines for Businesses
- The twenty-minute capture checklist
- What three working days’ notice meant
- Every figure, with its source
Every page in this section
- Trustpilot removed your reviews
- Save your Trustpilot reviews before they disappear
- Find your deleted Trustpilot profile on the Wayback Machine
- Publish what you recovered — the method, free to copy
- The notice was three working days
- What happens when a profile is removed
- When your customers are asked for proof of purchase
- When five-star reviews disappear one at a time
- What this record does not claim