If Trustpilot removed your reviews
When your customers are asked for proof of purchase
A verification request puts the burden on the reviewer, not on you, and a genuine customer frequently cannot meet it — the order was years ago, the confirmation email is gone, the purchase was made by a spouse, or it went through a marketplace under a different name. A review that disappears for that reason was not shown to be false. It was shown to be old.
Why genuine reviews fail verification
The reviews in this record span several years and 29 countries. A customer who wrote in 2019 about an order placed in 2018 is being asked, years later, to produce a document they had no reason to keep. Whether they can is a fact about their filing, not about the review.
This record does not allege how any particular verification request was handled. It records the asymmetry, which is visible from the facts alone: the business is not the party asked, cannot answer on the customer’s behalf, and often cannot find out what was asked or what happened.
What a business can do instead
Match the reviews against your own order records, and publish the match rate honestly. Here, each of the 196 recovered reviews was checked against the company’s own database twice over, independently — once by reviewer name, once by review text.
102 of 196 matched: 70 by name, 77 by text, overlapping. That number is published as it fell. The 94 that did not match are not thereby suspect; customers review under nicknames, first names, initials, a partner’s account, or an email that differs from the one on the order. The record says that, publishes the figure, and lets the reader weigh it.
A match rate published whole is worth considerably more than a match rate quoted selectively, and a reader can tell the difference immediately.
One review that came back a different way
One review in this record was supplied not by a screenshot but by the customer herself, from her own message of 16 August 2022, after the profile was gone. It is published here with her words unaltered.
Your customers may hold copies of their own reviews. It is worth asking them before you conclude a review is unrecoverable.
Questions
- Can Trustpilot remove a review if the customer cannot prove purchase?
- Trustpilot’s verification practice is a matter for Trustpilot and its published policies, which change; this record documents one company’s experience and makes no claim about how any request was decided.
- How do you show a review is genuine without a receipt?
- Match it against your own order records by name and by text, publish the match rate exactly as it falls including the proportion that does not match, and publish the screenshot beside the text so the transcription itself can be checked.
Where to go next
Every page in this section
- Trustpilot removed your reviews
- “Bad fit” — and nothing to correct
- Save your Trustpilot reviews before they disappear
- Find your deleted Trustpilot profile on the Wayback Machine
- Publish what you recovered — the method, free to copy
- The notice was three working days
- What happens when a profile is removed
- When five-star reviews disappear one at a time
- What this record does not claim